Starting from the
discussion about prices, I’d like to approach the topic from the other side for once. I want to emphasize that this is not about the designers’ point of view. But of course designers also use other people’s patterns, so they are warmly invited to join the discussion too. What I’m interested in is what you expect when you choose a pattern—whether it’s free online, from a magazine, a purchased CP pattern, or bought somewhere else. I’d also like to explicitly include all the techniques represented here.
Speaking for myself, the criterion that makes a good pattern is that it gets me to the goal, meaning I want a finished result that satisfies me. I don’t care whether the pattern is only in written form, whether it includes knitting or crochet charts, or 100 clear photos; what matters to me is that the pattern is correct. I should add that I’m from the pre-internet generation, and downloadable PDFs didn’t exist at the beginning of my crafting career. What I had available for learning were magazines, where the patterns were often very concise. Nevertheless, I can’t remember a single pattern from that time that didn’t deliver the desired result, even if the pattern for a sweater in 5 sizes fit on half a page.
Today we are far removed from patterns like that. At least in the download area, many designers boast about providing 30 pages or more of pattern instructions in order to meet everyone’s needs. Have consumers’ expectations changed too?
P.S.: Designers, please don’t launch into detailed descriptions of how you handle this in your own patterns—this is solely about your perspective as people who do crafts yourselves.