Forum Categories
Quick to Target
Browse Categories
Community & Help

historically accurate knitting?

102 Posts Recent Started
Sunday, October 29, 2023 at 3:51 PM
The picture is from a museum, farmhouse, 18th century.

Knitting machines didn’t exist until the 19th century, right? In any case, this certainly isn’t hand-knitted, and the yarn is also machine-made. Besides, the cotton is finished, which didn’t exist until the late 19th century.

Somehow that doesn’t fit the time period. What do you think—how should we imagine a farmer’s sock in the 18th century?

102 Posts Recent Started
Sunday, October 29, 2023 at 4:05 PM
I checked again—the exhibits date from the 19th to the early 20th century.

3426 Posts Recent Started
Monday, October 30, 2023 at 12:03 PM
Hi!

I’d find it pretty strange if the sock were made of cotton at all. Back then, socks were only knitted from pure wool. And that wool certainly wasn’t nearly as smooth—and especially not as shiny—as you describe.
I think the exhibition took the “easy way out” and used a modern-day sock. I also believe that, historically speaking, if the stocking were “authentic,” it would have to have one or two patches here and there.
Were you able to touch the stocking, or was it displayed in an “open space”? If so, it seems very likely to me that they didn’t display an original. Or was it behind glass?

Best regards

102 Posts Recent Started
Tuesday, October 31, 2023 at 1:37 PM
The display is based on historical accounts and isn’t authentic.

My photos behind glass are unusable; the photo here is of a sock in an open space. Of course, I didn’t touch anything anyway.

The material was just a guess on my part—it doesn’t look like wool.

During the Industrial Age, there were already cheap mass-produced goods that, in theory, people in rural areas could afford.

But I also think this is far from historically accurate. Does anyone happen to know of any books or museums where you can see historically accurate knitwear? I’d love to see the yarn, stitch pattern, and knitting pattern for it.

Write Reply

Please register or Log in!

Latest comments

2 actual comments last by rusalki01
6 actual comments last by herta_tappler
7 actual comments last by herta_tappler
4 actual comments last by veronika-t15
9 actual comments last by rusalki01
12 actual comments last by Schnuckelina
2 actual comments last by Schnuckelina
10 actual comments last by bea-pomp
9 actual comments last by Akela
4 actual comments last by Libelle11
1 actual comment last by veronika-t15
5 actual comments last by SabinesFadenspiel

Popular patterns

Top patterns from elealindadesign from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from Natalija from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from wooly-ways from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from KuemaTutorials from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from elke-eder from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from elke-eder from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from Melknits from the Knitting category!
Top patterns from elke-eder from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from elke-eder from the Crochet category!
Top patterns from Schnuckelina from the Felting category!
Top patterns from _petitbonnet_ from the Crochet category!
More top patterns

Free patterns

Top patterns from MorbenDesign from the category!
Top patterns from MommyPatterns from the category!
Top patterns from MorbenDesign from the category!
Top patterns from jennysideenreich from the category!
Top patterns from MorbenDesign from the category!
Top patterns from MorbenDesign from the category!
Top patterns from Hobbii from the category!
Top patterns from Miralay from the category!
Top patterns from KleinesFeines from the category!
Top patterns from Hobbii from the category!
Top patterns from Hobbii from the category!
Top patterns from CrochetGiftsShop from the category!
Top patterns from moonlighthook from the category!
Top patterns from MorbenDesign from the category!
Top patterns from MorbenDesign from the category!
Top patterns from Dianas-kleiner-Haekelshop from the category!
Top patterns from moonlighthook from the category!
Top patterns from ternuraamigurumi from the category!
Top patterns from MyCuties_Design from the category!
Top patterns from martina-supova from the category!
Top patterns from Hobbii from the category!
Top patterns from Colorfuldreams from the category!
Top patterns from DIY-4U from the category!
Top patterns from christina-lemberger from the category!
More free patterns

Win shopping credit every month!

42 prizes / total value €300: 30×€5, 10×€10, 2×€25 – simply activate the newsletter. No purchase necessary. Unsubscribe at any time. Prizes are awarded as Crazypatterns shopping credit. Learn more